People ask this like it is either/or. It isn't. An external drive and a cloud backup protect you from completely different disasters, and neither one covers the other's blind spot. Here is exactly what each one saves you from, what they really cost in 2026, and which one to set up first if you can only do one thing this week.
If you have nothing at all right now, start with cloud backup. Not because it is better, but because it covers the one disaster you can never undo: your computer and everything near it being destroyed or stolen at the same time. Then add an external drive when you can. If you already own a drive that is sitting in a drawer, plug it in tonight — a backup you own is worth more than a backup you are planning.
| External hard drive | Cloud backup (online backup) | |
|---|---|---|
| What it costs | One payment, roughly $60–$90 for a 2 TB portable drive | Free for small amounts, then a monthly or yearly fee |
| Speed | Very fast — restoring 500 GB takes a couple of hours | Slow — restoring 500 GB can take days on home internet |
| Runs by itself? | Only when you remember to plug it in | Yes, quietly in the background |
| Kept away from your house? | No, unless you physically store it elsewhere | Yes, automatically |
| Biggest weakness | It is in the same building as your computer | It depends on an account, a company, and your internet |
| Lifespan | Wears out. Plan on replacing it every 4–5 years | Lasts as long as you keep paying |
Comparing them on price and speed misses the point. The real question is which specific bad day does each one rescue you from. Here is the honest version.
| If this happens… | External drive | Cloud backup |
|---|---|---|
| The drive inside your computer dies | Saves you | Saves you |
| You delete something by accident | Saves you, if the backup ran before you deleted it | Saves you, if it keeps old versions |
| Your laptop is stolen | Only if the drive was somewhere else | Saves you |
| Fire, flood, or burst pipe | No — the drive burns with the computer | Saves you |
| Ransomware encrypts your files | Only if the drive was unplugged at the time | Only if it keeps old versions |
| You get locked out of your cloud account | Saves you | No |
| The cloud company folds or triples the price | Saves you | No |
| Your internet is out for a week | Saves you | No |
Read down those two columns and the answer stops being a debate. Every row one of them fails, the other one covers. That is not a coincidence — it is the whole reason the professional advice has always been to use both.
This is the single most expensive misunderstanding in this whole subject, and almost everyone reading this has it.
Google Drive, OneDrive, Dropbox and iCloud are sync services. Their job is to make your files look identical everywhere. That is a genuinely useful thing, and it is not a backup.
Here is why it matters. If you delete a file on your computer, sync does what it is designed to do — it deletes it everywhere else too. Google's own support page says it plainly: files you move to the trash are "deleted forever after 30 days", and "any files you put in the trash are put in the trash everywhere."
So if you delete a folder of photos in March and only notice in May, sync has already carried out your instruction on every device you own. Nothing malicious happened. The system worked exactly as designed. The photos are gone.
A real backup behaves differently. It keeps old versions, so you can go back to how things were on a date you choose, even if the mistake happened months ago and you never noticed.
Actual prices, checked in September 2026. Prices move, so treat these as the shape of the market rather than a quote.
| Option | Price | Is it a real backup? |
|---|---|---|
| 2 TB portable external drive | Roughly $60–$90, paid once | Yes, if you run backup software to it |
| Backblaze Personal Backup | $99 a year, unlimited data from one computer | Yes — this is proper backup |
| IDrive Personal, 5 TB | $6.99 a month billed yearly, or $11.99 month to month | Yes |
| Google Drive free tier | Free, 15 GB shared across Gmail and Photos | No — sync only |
| Google One, 100 GB | About $2 a month | No — sync only |
| iCloud free tier | Free, 5 GB | No — sync only |
| iCloud+ 50 GB / 200 GB | $0.99 / $2.99 a month | No — sync only |
The number that surprises people: a drive plus a year of proper cloud backup is under $200 for the first year, and under $100 a year after that. That is the entire cost of never losing a photograph again.
People argue about this with no numbers, so here are some real ones. Backblaze runs a very large fleet of hard drives and publishes the failure rates every year. Across 344,196 drives in 2025, the annualised failure rate was 1.36%, with a lifetime rate of 1.30%.
Roughly one drive in seventy-four failed that year. That sounds reassuring until you sit with it: over five years, in a house with a few computers and a couple of external drives, the odds of something failing stop being remote.
And two honest caveats, because the number is often quoted badly:
Find the line that sounds like you.
The rule the professionals use is called 3-2-1, and it is much simpler than it sounds:
That is it. A single drive plus a single cloud backup already satisfies all three lines. You do not need a complicated setup, a server in a cupboard, or expensive software.
Neither is better — they fail in opposite ways. A drive is faster and cheaper over time and works with no internet, but it sits in the same building as your computer, so a fire, flood or burglary takes both. Cloud backup survives losing the whole house, but it is slow to restore from and depends on an account staying accessible. Using one of each removes both weaknesses.
For ordinary personal files, yes. Reputable services encrypt your data in transit and while stored, and several let you set a private encryption key so even the company cannot read your files. The realistic risks are not hackers breaking into the datacentre — they are losing access to your own account, or the service shutting down. That is precisely why you keep a local copy as well.
Plan on four to five years for a spinning hard drive in normal home use, though many last longer and some fail in the first year. Solid-state drives have no moving parts and survive being dropped much better, but they cost more per terabyte. Either way, treat the drive as something that expires rather than something permanent, and replace it before it stops working rather than after.
Yes. Those are sync services. They copy your changes everywhere, including your deletions and any damage to a file. They also usually keep deleted items for only about 30 days. They are a good offsite copy of your current files, and they are not protection against a mistake you notice late.
A single external drive using the backup software already built into Windows or macOS costs nothing beyond the drive itself. Add one paid cloud backup service and you have covered every scenario in the table above for well under $10 a month. There is no cheaper complete answer, and free cloud storage on its own is not a substitute.
Yes, and Windows keeps each computer in its own folder so they cannot overwrite each other. One warning: when you set up the second computer, Windows may offer to reuse the existing backup on the drive with the option already ticked. Untick it, or you will merge one machine's backup into the other's.
If you are worried about ransomware, yes — a drive that is not connected cannot be encrypted. The trade-off is that a drive you have to remember to plug in is a drive you will eventually forget. If you know yourself well enough to know you will forget, leave it connected and make sure your cloud backup keeps old versions, so you still have a way back.
I will set up both halves for you — cloud backup and an external drive — configured correctly, checked, and proven with a real restore test so you know it works. No jargon, no subscriptions you did not ask for. See the done-for-you service →
The 3-2-1 rule explained · Back up your phone photos · Best free cloud storage